Pembicaraan Pengguna:C1K98V

Halo, C1K98V.

Selamat datang di Wikipedia bahasa Indonesia!

Memulai

• Bacalah halaman Pengantar Wikipedia terlebih dahulu.
• Baca juga informasi tentang berkontribusi di Wikipedia.
• Tuliskan juga sedikit profil Anda di Pengguna:C1K98V, halaman pribadi Anda, agar kami dapat lebih mengenal Anda.
• Lihat pula aturan yang disederhanakan sebelum melanjutkan.

Tips

• Selalu tanda tangani pertanyaan Anda di Warung Kopi atau halaman pembicaraan dengan mengetikkan ~~~~ pada akhir kalimat Anda.
• Jangan takut! Anda tidak perlu takut salah ketika menyunting atau membuat halaman baru, menambahkan, atau menghapus kalimat.

Selamat menjelajah, kami menunggu suntingan Anda di Wikipedia bahasa Indonesia!

Welcome! If you do not understand Indonesian language, you may want to visit the embassy or find users who speak your language. Enjoy!

ustad abu gosok (bicara) 7 Agustus 2022 00.04 (UTC)

en:Templat:Firstarticle if new

Usulan penghapusan Pratik Sehajpal

Artikel Pratik Sehajpal telah diusulkan untuk dihapus karena beberapa alasan berikut:

Saya mengajukan penghapusan artikel ini karena saya melihat artikelnya dihapus di Wikipedia Inggris. Ini buktinya

Meskipun Wikipedia sangat mengapresiasi kontribusi yang membangun, suatu halaman bisa saja dihapus karena beberapa alasan.

Anda dapat menghalangi usulan penghapusan dengan cara menghapus peringatan {{proposed deletion/dated}}, tetapi tolong sertakan alasan Anda melakukan hal tersebut di ringkasan suntingan Anda atau di halaman pembicaraan artikel tersebut.

Pertimbangkan untuk mengembangkan halaman terkait yang menjadi sasaran dari usulan penghapusan. Menghapus {{proposed deletion/dated}} akan menghentikan proses usulan penghapusan, tetapi proses penghapusan lain masih tetap ada. Sebagai contoh, proses penghapusan cepat dapat menghasilkan proses penghapusan tanpa melalui diskusi terlebih dahulu, sedangkan proses artikel untuk dihapus mengizinkan diskusi untuk mendapatkan konsensus perihal penghapusan. Badak Jawa (bicara) 23 Agustus 2024 08.08 (UTC)

Penghapusan cepat atas halaman Pratik Sehajpal

Peringatan

Halaman berjudul Pratik Sehajpal telah dihapus berdasarkan kebijakan penghapusan cepat Wikipedia, secara khusus dengan alasan:

Komentar Pengguna:Badak Jawa: [[Wikipedia:Usulan penghapusan/Saya mengajukan penghapusan artikel ini karena saya melihat artikelnya dihapus di Wikipedia Inggris. Sehajpal&type=&user= Ini buktinya]]

Menurut kriteria penghapusan cepat, halaman yang memenuhi beberapa ketentuan dapat dihapus kapan saja dan tanpa peringatan.

Harap tidak menulis ulang artikel tersebut dengan konten yang sama, tanpa menyelesaikan masalah yang menjadi dasar penghapusan. Namun demikian, jangan ragu untuk menambahkan informasi yang sesuai dengan kebijakan dan pedoman Wikipedia. Jika Anda berpikir halaman ini tidak sepatutnya dihapus atas dasar ini, atau Anda ingin mendapatkan kembali tulisan yang sudah dihapus unutuk referensi dan pengembangan, maka Anda dapat menghubungi pengurus yang melakukan tindakan penghapusan, atau jika perbaikan sudah dilakukan maka permohonan dapat diajukan pada halaman ini.

MITGATVM^{「b • k • e」} 23 Agustus 2024 09.26 (UTC)

@MITGATVM terima kasih Badak Jawa (bicara) 23 Agustus 2024 09.33 (UTC)

Hello MITGATVM, I hope you're doing well. It is really shameful that you deleted the article. Just because @Badak Jawa tagged it for deletion with the silly rationale (deleted on English Wikipedia). You can go ahead and check with an admin (English Wikipedia) that the article which I created here has any relevance/similarity with English wikipedia article. I don't have any bad faith intention. I edit wikipedia as it's my passion. You are most welcome to delete all my contributions and block me. Thanks for your consideration C1K98V ^{(💬 ✒️ 📂)} 23 Agustus 2024 10.04 (UTC)

If the article has been removed on the English Wikipedia on the grounds that it is not notable then the Indonesian Wikipedia follows suit. We don't care about the similarity of the article in the Wikipedia English but what we care about is whether the character is notable who has a large social media following and is widely discussed by trusted non trivia media Badak Jawa (bicara) 23 Agustus 2024 10.10 (UTC)

Have you filed an objection discussion on the English Wikipedia so that the article can be reinstated by the administrators? Badak Jawa (bicara) 23 Agustus 2024 10.11 (UTC)

I've seen the discussion here and there's a lot of support for deleting the article. Badak Jawa (bicara) 23 Agustus 2024 10.13 (UTC)

@Badak Jawa, @MITGATVM, Initially, I didn't create the article or participated in the deletion discussion on english wikipedia. And you have tagged in 2024 and deleted it based on English Wikipedia as it was deleted on the ground of being a notability issue (The english wikipedia discussion happened three years ago in 2021). So, I take my words back and I apologize, I understood now that indonesian wikipedia has no policy of its own and it works based on English Wikipedia. Going forward I will search and suggest the article which should be deleted here (Just want to be sure if an article lets say "XYZ" on Indonesia wikipedia is in stable condition, but english wikipedia article gets deleted on the ground of blatant advertising/promotion. So, an indonesian wikipedia admin will take that into consideration and delete the article stating the article was created in violations of English wikipedia policy and the content was blatant advertising/promotion). Kindly answer my query. Thanks for your consideration C1K98V ^{(💬 ✒️ 📂)} 23 Agustus 2024 10.42 (UTC)

@C1K98V Clearly, most of the policies on the Indonesian Wikipedia are oriented towards the English Wikipedia. After all, the character is from India where Indonesians don't know the character and has no significance, except for Indonesian characters who (maybe) deserve to be placed in this Wikipedia language but not in other Wikipedia languages. MITGATVM^{「b • k • e」} 23 Agustus 2024 11.06 (UTC)

@MITGATVM, Correct me if I get you wrong, you mean to say Indian personalities don't deserve an article on Indonesia language wikipedia or Indonesian personalities don't deserve an article on other languages wikipedias (including English wikipedia). If this is what you believe then I doubt who made you an admin, the community supported a wrong candidate. Indonesian Wikipedia is being managed by an incompetent user, admin and reader. I wish that the community read this discussion. Glad you answered all my query, and cleared my doubts. I don't intend to edit indonesian wikipedia anymore. Thanks for your consideration C1K98V ^{(💬 ✒️ 📂)} 23 Agustus 2024 11.23 (UTC)

Sorry for the lack of satisfaction. Perhaps my temporary solution is to move the page to your user subpage, as Draft namespace is not enabled on this wiki. MITGATVM^{「b • k • e」} 23 Agustus 2024 11.48 (UTC)

No no, I'm totally satisfied. Who said that I'm not satisfied with your admin action. I'm discussing this because you posted on my talkpage that you agreed with an indonesian @Badak Jawa, who tagged the article for deletion with the rationale deleted on English Wikipedia. Firstly, I didn't think or assume that you are incompetent admin. But your response to my question proved it (incompetent for the role). I know it's not your task to include/delete/translate an article from other language Wikipedia. But it is also a wrong judgement to include or delete articles if it's not present on English Wikipedia. The page was live on English wikipedia, so I created it here. I was also intending to create the same article in Hindi and Simple wikipedia, but I was occupied in some or other task and forgotten it. And why I'm saying all this is because you don't consider discussing it with an English wikipedia admin (the enwiki article title is protected due to repetitive creation). And I'm sure that you haven't checked the english wikipedia log that I didn't create the article. If you still stand by your comments that the subject will become notable when the english wikipedia article is live again then I don't want any further admin action from you. Thanks for your consideration C1K98V ^{(💬 ✒️ 📂)} 23 Agustus 2024 12.26 (UTC)

You're welcome. I checked the page logs and you never created the page. In conclusion, the deletion of a page in another Wikipedia language can change how one perceives that page. MITGATVM^{「b • k • e」} 23 Agustus 2024 12.34 (UTC)

Permission to help clear this problem, to clear his sentence. He intended to state that if, someone doesn't have notable or didn't have a high profile in account. Then, the pages will be considered as promotion or advertisement. And you can check WP:TOKOH for more information :) Pinkash ^{Ngobrol yuk} 23 Agustus 2024 12.21 (UTC)

@PinkDash, The whole discussion was for the deletion rationale which was used by @Badak Jawa "I am requesting the deletion of this article because I saw it deleted on English Wikipedia. Here is the proof." I was not well aware about how Indonesian Wikipedia works. So, I'm glad that @MITGATVM helped me. I'm not here to do blatantly advertisement or promotion. And now everything is sorted. Thanks C1K98V ^{(💬 ✒️ 📂)} 23 Agustus 2024 12.38 (UTC)

Ahhh alright then, have a nice day tho. :) Pinkash ^{Ngobrol yuk} 23 Agustus 2024 12.50 (UTC)