Pengguna:Dedhert.Jr/Uji halaman 06.2

Portal

ProyekWiki

Diskusi

Penilaian

Anggota

Konten

Kategori

Halaman Ini merupakan proses untuk membahas dan menentukan apakah artikel matematika sebaiknya diberi status kelas-A atau tidak. Proses ini bertujuan untuk memperbaiki dan mendukung artikel matematika menjadi artikel berstatuskan kelas-A, meninjau apakah artikel kelas-A memenuhi standar (dengan membuat perubahan ketika diperlukan), atau membahas tentang menurunkan artikel yang berstatuskan kelas-A.

Tujuan

Tujuan penilaian kelas-A dan proses peninjauannya adalah:

1. Mengenali artikel-artikel yang berkualitas, dan membuat penetapan status kelas-A yang kurang subjektif.
2. Mendorong artikel yang sedang ditinjau untuk ditingkatkan, daripada mengharapkannya sempurna sebelum diiusul.
3. Mendorong diskusi yang bersifat kolegial daripada proses persetujuan yang bersifat bertentangan.

Proses

Menominasikan artikel

Any editor may nominate an article for A-class rating discussion. To do so:

1. Add the argument |ACD=yes to the end of the {{maths rating}} template near the top of the article's talk page. Capitalization is important. If there is no maths rating template, you may add one. Save the page.
2. The sentence "A discussion on promoting this article to A-class status or reviewing this status is underway." will appear in the math project banner. Click the link "discussion".
3. Enter {{subst:maths acd}} ~~~~ into the empty page and save. If the article has previously been nominated for an A-class rating, please archive the previous discussion by moving (not copying) it to an archive page, which will leave a redirect. Replace this redirect with the code above.
4. Add the line {{Wikipedia:WikiProject Mathematics/A-class rating/Name of nominated article}} to the top of the section Current discussions below.
5. You may like to further publicise the review by listing it at the top of Wikipedia:WikiProject Mathematics/Current activity.

Leaving a comment

All editors are welcome to comment on the discussion page. The criteria should be kept in mind, but editors are free to use their own judgement about the quality of an article.

In light of the goals above, reviewers should make an effort to improve the article rather than making comments about minor flaws. Thus comments should be limited to whether a reviewer supports the A-class rating or has a serious objection to it. Objections over relatively minor issues of writing style or formatting should be avoided; a comprehensive, accurate, well sourced, and decently written article should qualify for A-class status even if it could use further copyediting. The "support"/"oppose" approach to review should be avoided as far as possible.

Closing the discussion

Any editor may close the discussion after seven days, although common sense should be used not to close a discussion that is still receiving many comments, or where the article is still improving significantly.

To close a discussion:

1. Remove the |ACD=yes parameter from the {{maths rating}} template in the article's talk page.
2. If there are no remaining substantial objections, change the class= parameter in the {{maths rating}} template to read class=A-class. If there are substantial objections and the article is not already rated A-class, leave the rating unchanged. If it is rated A-class, assign it another rating using the criteria.
3. Move the line {{Wikipedia:WikiProject Mathematics/A-class rating/Name of nominated article}} from the list of requests below to the current archive page.
4. Add {{subst:archive top}} and {{subst:archive bottom}} to the top and bottom of the discussion subpage, respectively.

Kriteria

Kemungkinan pertimbangan

sebuah artikel:

• benar?
• cukup lengkap dan seimbang?
• jelas?
• menarik?
• dapat diakses secara wajar, mengingat topiknya?

• tatabahasa, pengejaan yang benar, dan mengetik dengan baik?
• diilustrasikan dengan tepat, jika ada?
• terhubung dengan baik?
• membantu dalam memberikan referensi dan sumber daya tambahan?

Penyunting dapat mempertimbangkan uraian berikut, dan pertanyaan di sidebar, saat memutuskan apakah akan mendukung peringkat kelas-A.

Artikel matematika kelas A sangat berguna bagi pembaca yang dituju dan memberikan perlakuan yang benar dan cukup lengkap tentang subjeknya. Ini adalah model untuk artikel matematika lainnya.

The article contains sufficient motivation for the topic. It places the topic in context by providing both an appropriate historical account as well as links to related areas of contemporary mathematics.

The article's breadth, completeness, and balance have no flaws apparent to a nonexpert reader. A nonmathematician will typically find nothing wanting, although the article may omit a few minor points. Minor edits and adjustments might improve the article, however, particularly if made by an expert in the area.

The article meets the spirit of the Wikipedia style manual, the manual of style for mathematics, and the scientific citation guidelines.